DriveSize

2021 Volkswagen ID.4 vs 2020 Tesla Model Y

Side view of the 2020 Tesla Model Y
Side view of the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4

Volkswagen ID.4

2021

Tesla Model Y

2020

Select unit of measurement:

Which is bigger, the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4 or 2020 Tesla Model Y?

Key dimensions: length, width, height

The 2020 Tesla Model Y measures an extra 16.7 cm in length, providing a slightly more substantial footprint on the road than the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4. The 2020 Tesla Model Y’s 6.9 cm width advantage over the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4 might mean a wider interior cabin with more elbow room. On paper, the 2020 Tesla Model Y is taller by 1.2 cm, but just to look at, they appear essentially the same height. The 2020 Tesla Model Y is only 1.2 cm higher off the tarmac, maintaining a very similar ground clearance to the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4. With a 12.4 cm longer wheelbase, the 2020 Tesla Model Y steps into a more comfortable tier of ride quality than the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4.

Measurements

Length

458.4 cm

475.1 cm (+16.7)

Height

161.2 cm

162.4 cm (+1.2)

Width (excluding mirrors)

185.2 cm

192.1 cm (+6.9)

Width (including mirrors)

210.8 cm

212.9 cm (+1.2)

Ground clearance

16 cm

17.2 cm (+12.4)

Wheelbase

276.6 cm

289 cm (+0.6)

How each car compares with its class average

Length

458.4 cm

5.8 cm longer than the average Crossover

475.1 cm

22.5 cm longer than the average Crossover

Height

161.2 cm

1.6 cm shorter than the average Crossover

162.4 cm

0.4 cm shorter than the average Crossover

Width (excluding mirrors)

185.2 cm

0.3 cm wider than the average Crossover

192.1 cm

7.2 cm wider than the average Crossover

Width (including mirrors)

210.8 cm

4.4 cm wider than the average Crossover

212.9 cm

6.5 cm wider than the average Crossover

Ground clearance

16 cm

2.1 cm less ground clearance than the average Crossover

17.2 cm

0.9 cm less ground clearance than the average Crossover

Wheelbase

276.6 cm

4.2 cm longer wheelbase than the average Crossover

289 cm

16.6 cm longer wheelbase than the average Crossover

Front view

Front view of the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4
Front view of the 2020 Tesla Model Y

Cargo Capacity: which has more space?

Standard and largest cargo capacity

This is a significant split in design; the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4 offers a massive 4 L advantage for your luggage, yet the 2020 Tesla Model Y counters with a huge 223 L lead for total hauling with the seats down.

Measurements

Standard cargo capacity (VDA)

The standard cargo capacity using VDA, the method commonly used globally.

This is the manufacturer's normal published figure; it does not imply a particular seat configuration.

543 L

N/A

Largest cargo capacity (VDA)

The largest cargo capacity using VDA, the method commonly used globally.

If only one VDA figure is published, the standard and largest values are the same.

1,575 L

N/A

Standard cargo capacity (SAE)

The standard cargo capacity using SAE, the method commonly used in the US.

This is the manufacturer's normal published figure; it does not imply a particular seat configuration.

858 L (+4)

854 L

Largest cargo capacity (SAE)

The largest cargo capacity using SAE, the method commonly used in the US.

If only one SAE figure is published, the standard and largest values are the same.

1,818 L

2,041 L (+223)

Frunk capacity

N/A

117 L

Cargo space vs length

This DriveSize metric divides blended cargo volume by overall vehicle length.

Blended cargo uses 65% of the standard figure and 35% of the largest figure, using VDA where available and SAE otherwise.

197.3 L per m

267.2 L per m (+69.9)

Cargo space vs footprint

This DriveSize metric divides blended cargo volume by footprint.

Blended cargo uses 65% of the standard figure and 35% of the largest figure, using VDA where available and SAE otherwise.

It helps show how efficiently a car turns exterior area into usable cargo space.

106.5 L per m²

139.1 L per m² (+32.6)

How each car compares with its class average

Standard cargo capacity (VDA)

The standard cargo capacity using VDA, the method commonly used globally.

This is the manufacturer's normal published figure; it does not imply a particular seat configuration.

543 L

98 L more cargo volume than the average Crossover

N/A

Largest cargo capacity (VDA)

The largest cargo capacity using VDA, the method commonly used globally.

If only one VDA figure is published, the standard and largest values are the same.

1,575 L

67 L more cargo volume than the average Crossover

N/A

Standard cargo capacity (SAE)

The standard cargo capacity using SAE, the method commonly used in the US.

This is the manufacturer's normal published figure; it does not imply a particular seat configuration.

858 L

119 L more cargo volume than the average Crossover

854 L

115 L more cargo volume than the average Crossover

Largest cargo capacity (SAE)

The largest cargo capacity using SAE, the method commonly used in the US.

If only one SAE figure is published, the standard and largest values are the same.

1,818 L

53 L less cargo volume than the average Crossover

2,041 L

170 L more cargo volume than the average Crossover

DriveSize space efficiency score

DriveSize space efficiency compares blended cargo volume per square meter of footprint with the class average.

Blended cargo uses 65% of the standard figure and 35% of the largest figure within the selected cargo measurement method.

VDA scores compare with VDA class averages, and SAE scores compare with SAE class averages. Around 100% means in line with class average.

108%

VDA: above class average (+8%)

106%

SAE: above class average (+6%)

Rear view

Rear view of the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4
Rear view of the 2020 Tesla Model Y

Details

Doors, seats, weight, maneuverability

Both the 2020 Tesla Model Y and 2021 Volkswagen ID.4 come with a 5-door setup, providing identical passenger access. In terms of passenger capacity, there is no difference here, with both vehicles providing a maximum of 5 seats. If you drive these cars, you'll notice the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4 is significantly more responsive in U-turns, clearing them with 1.9 m to spare over the 2020 Tesla Model Y.

Measurements

Doors

5

5

Max. seats

5

5

Turning circle

10.2 m

12.1 m (+1.9)

Curb weight

1,891 kg

N/A

How each car compares with its class average

Turning circle

10.2 m

1 m smaller turning circle than the average Crossover

12.1 m

0.9 m larger turning circle than the average Crossover

Curb weight

1,891 kg

259 kg heavier than the average Crossover

N/A

DriveSize manoeuvrability score

DriveSize manoeuvrability score combines turning circle and footprint, with turning circle weighted more heavily.

Around 100% means in line with the class average; higher scores indicate better manoeuvrability relative to similar cars.

107%

7% more manoeuvrable than the average Crossover

93%

7% less manoeuvrable than the average Crossover

Parking

Will the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4 or 2020 Tesla Model Y fit in a standard parking space?

2021 Volkswagen ID.4 parking fit score

DriveSize compares the car's width and length with typical parking-space sizes by region.

Vehicle dimensions are rounded up and available side or length clearance is rounded down.

Side clearance is based on body width excluding mirrors where available; real spaces can vary because of mirrors, walls, pillars, kerbs, bay markings, and nearby cars.

OK

For an average USA / Canada space: body side clearance is 44.5 cm per side (excluding mirrors), and length clearance is 45.5 cm at each end.

Body side clearance (excluding mirrors)

44.5 cm

Length clearance (at each end)

45.5 cm

2020 Tesla Model Y parking fit score

DriveSize compares the car's width and length with typical parking-space sizes by region.

Vehicle dimensions are rounded up and available side or length clearance is rounded down.

Side clearance is based on body width excluding mirrors where available; real spaces can vary because of mirrors, walls, pillars, kerbs, bay markings, and nearby cars.

OK

For an average USA / Canada space: body side clearance is 41 cm per side (excluding mirrors), and length clearance is 37 cm at each end.

Body side clearance (excluding mirrors)

41 cm

Length clearance (at each end)

37 cm

Articles featuring these cars

View all

FAQs

Frequently asked questions

By DriveSize